amish shredded chicken sandwiches

, True Deb , I raised 3 boys in a small Ohio town and this was always at sporting events! Thanks. Thats how I was taught to make it. So glad you liked it. Step 2: Add in the remaining ingredients. To me all you taste is stuffing. Now Im a Hoosier and my sister-in-law tried was experimenting with the recipe and used Stove Top stuffing instead of crackers. No one has mentioned the hot chicken sandwiches at the Lions tent-Loudonville Free St Fair? It says to cook the chicken for a couple of hours and then add the other ingredients. I loved those sandwiches! Looking forward to giving this recipe a try. This recipe looks really flavorful. I am a buckeye and remember this sandwich at the concession stand at every football game. will make it to sell to help the Fire Dept. Somewhere along the line, this was changes and some started adding boxed chicken stuffing. I lived in Tiffin until my family moved when I was in the 6th Grade. , UPDATE: I used to shred my chicken by hand but I tried that Shredded Chicken Hack, and it worked! I crush a sleeve of buttery townhouse crackers add that to the chicken, add cream of chicken soup and a teaspoon of poultry seasoning. The origin of these chicken sandwiches from what I have been told is that it is a depression era dish. Thanks for the recipe and Ohio memory comments! Before you are ready to serve, add in the remaining ingredients and let everything cook together for 10 15 minutes. These sandwiches are very popular in this area (Ohio). I used to date a guy from alvada/new riegel ohio and these sandwiches were awesome. Whisk in milk. p.s. You may need to add a little more of your crackers/chips/breadcrumbs when you thaw it because it might get a little watered down. Step 5. The home and visiting teams loved them. I am from Fostoria, OH- Seneca Co. Lived here most of my life. Over the years it appears shredded chicken is more common north of I-70 than south100% of people in my hometown area of Lima know what this ismaybe 50% in the Columbus area.maybe 10% in Cincinnati. Add the melted butter, flour, baking powder, sugar, and salt to the egg and milk. Add the onions and chili powder. But I also love when people experience it for the first time! It was always the FAVORITE school cafeteria lunchno one packed on chicken sandwich day. Thank you. Also good on a plate w/o the bun! Up in Wapakoneta, Auglaize County, OH. Want to add a little more flavor, try substituting crackers with sour cream and onion potato chips. Perfect for large gatherings and easy weeknight meal prep thanks to the crockpot! (I live in Florida now, too!). So good. Especially if you are going to add in the other ingredients. Finding a Shredded Chicken Sandwich I love the drink pairing, root beer float- Perfect! Im from Vaughnsville now living in Fl. That would be the icing on the cake! Thanks for sharing this recipe. We always used potato chips and some bread. Thanks so much for sharing. We had their hot chicken/turkey sandwiches for every graduation and wedding reception. I grew up in Lima, Ohio, and still get these sandwiches at the DQ whenever I return. Oven- bake at 425 in a covered baking dish for 25-30 minutes, until the chicken reaches an internal temperature of 165F. Being a player, we werent able to get them during the game; however, the moms would always deliver us a huge box of leftover sandwiches after the game! I have lived North of the Ohio border for 30 years. Listen online, find out more about your favourite artists, and get music recommendations. Stir to combine. Was looking for something different to do with chicken because its just the 2 of us now trying not to make huge dinners and go with sandwiches and soups. I dont remember these sandwiches, most likely because I was a VERY picky eater!! It is funny how some like to keep their version too secret. Question for you. The "Shredded Chicken" sandwich has been a mainstay of poor people that stretched the protein by utilizing "picked" chicken carcasses and creating a substantial sandwich that is the heartbeat of anyone in the area over 40 years old. I grew up on these! Pour the broth down the side of the pot. Definitely on our rotation now. Combine shredded chicken, condensed soup, crushed crackers, and poultry seasoning in a large saucepan over medium heat. Cover and cook on low for 3-4 hours. If you do, let me know how it works and Ill update after I get to testing it. Our Mom took the sandwiches away, took out all the skin, then we enjoyed our sandwiches. Going to try it next time. If preparing to bake in oven, add extra broth . Excellent recipe and interesting comments. Pick the chicken (let it cool a bit so you dont burn your hands) being careful to remove all bones and skin. Preheat a 4-square waffle maker. Thanks for sharing! Im from Ohio and grew up with this sandwich that I love so much. Everyone brings a dish and I provide the meat. Ive got to try that next time. I may need to give it a try too. Test the noodles for doneness. My sisters and I have made them too! When the chicken is tender, transfer to a board and shred with two forks. My boss makes this sometimes for our birthday carry in lunches. I was at a loss of what to make. Yes! Let the pressure release naturally for 10 minutes, then quick release the remaining pressure. Let us know how it turned out for you. Separate the egg yolk and white, and reserve the egg white in a small bowl. Step 3: Heat until everything is thoroughly heated. Noodles and mashed potatoes. Then the next year they say, I hope you made those noodles. Ohio lives on in so many memories and the food we eat. Your email address will not be published. Thanks for the memories, everyone. Stir it and off. The best way to warm this is on low in a crockpotfor a few hours. Make the best tasting chicken even better by cooking at home or sharing recipes! The mixture can be made the day before and then heated in the slow cooker when ready to eat. And deep fried- that one to try! Cream of chicken soup You can substitute with cream of mushroom or cream of celery if you prefer. Betting it will become a requested fellowship dish! And have a great party! * Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Youre welcome, Youre welcome, Youre welcome! And no not from Ohio, I love the Thanksgiving twist on yours. Quick question, do I add the canned soup AND the broth to make the shredded chicken, or just the can of condensed soup no mixer? When the cooker cools down, Ill strain all the liquid off through a permanent coffee filter though any micro-mesh will work though. No one ever knows what Im talking about when I say I miss these yummy sandwiches!! This post may contain affiliate links. Thanks, again! This is popular way to make it in the Zanesville to Newark areas of Ohio all the way south to Corning and all the way north to millersburg. I used to go to Mount Vernon and Mansfield growing up. Served them at the firehouse!! Now I live in Florida and the same thing hereno one makes them. I am now in Florida and sometimes get a craving for these. Cover; cook on medium heat 7 min. Pour soup over the top. From Tiffin. Was not disappointed SOOOO good and cheap! Thanks for indulging him with this regional fave. I used Ritz crackers and grilled the buns with butter to not make it gluey, but rather crunchy. I grew up in Galion, OHIve lived in FL since 1985. In a bowl, mix together the remaining ingredients. People say, Whaaaat? I agree with some dill pickles are great. I grew up in Sidney, OH. My older siblings started school @ GH. Transfer dough to pizza pan. My family made these, and I still do, by cooking a whole chicken or breasts and and thighs with bone in and skin on to make a rich broth. (Kind of like putting katchup on eggs!) By that time they were so old and tough that all one could do was make creamed chicken and serve it in buns or over biscuits. There was a meal at the church afterward with so much delicious food, including a big pile of buns and a big dish of the chicken mix. Or if you prefer you can use your hands. Might add a nice little flavor to it too. I love the idea of adding cream cheese! Wow, Mary, thank you for such a quick reply!! Thank you for stopping by! paprika Crackers or slider buns Serve with slider buns, crackers or pita chips Directions 1 Mix all ingredients together. Always brought to family reunions and sold at football games. I guess I should start appreciating them more. You will find them being served at all kinds of gatherings, from parties to potlucks and they are sold at most local ice cream shops. In a large bowl combine the shredded chicken, mayo, celery, grapes, cashews, Mrs. Unfortunately, the TSA at the Columbus airport confiscated it DENIED! I live in Sidney, Ohio and we buy them from the Chilly Jillys. Vernon, Ohio and now live in Louisiana. I have loved hearing where you all have found this hot chicken sandwich recipe over the years; from the concession stand to being on the menu as the Dairy Queen shredded chicken sandwich (read all the comments below and add yours!) That is now his favorite shredded chicken sandwich. Total Time 30 Minutes Serving Size 6 Servings Ingredients Directions Recipe Nutrition Information - Per Serving Made With TAGS American Main Dish Sandwiches 300 Calories or Less Oatmeal, huh. Then mix in the other casserole ingredients as instructed. In a medium bowl, mix all together. I want to triple this recipe for a gathering and already have chicken cut up to use. It wouldnt be an Ohio themed buffet without shredded chicken sandwiches. Cover and cook on low for 3-4 hours or until the chicken is shreddable. We use 3 of the large cans of pulled chicken and one large can of cream of chicken. Maybe another reader can chime in on their experience. I also love spending time with my family and getting away when I can to the lake. If you try it, let me know how it turns out! My mother used to crush up bags of oyster crackers to mix in, and would add a dollop of sour cream for a little added zip and creaminess. If its not there yet, its probably because of the thickness of the liquid, which is adjustable with a bit more flour (but it would need to be cooked again to not taste like raw flour) or Ill use a small bit of cornstarch which only takes a second to thicken up in hot liquid and is neutral in flavor. Stir to combine. Thank you! If shopping was a sport, she would actually set records for it. Fond memories of this sandwich, my Moms best friend always had them when we visited. What a great recipe. If you love easy classic recipes, I have a few more of my familys favorites that you might enjoy. for? I live wyoming now. Cook on high for 3 hours and then shred the chicken. My 26 yr old daughter said why dont you make Ohio Shedded chicken sandwiches? So here I am looking up the recipe. Turn the heat on medium and cook until all of the ingredients are thoroughly heated through. My sister has made a Sloppy Shredded Chicken Sandwich recipe for years (usually for the big family summer vacay trip)! Im from Ohio and I had no idea hot chicken sandwiches were a thing here! When I need to de-stress, I head into the kitchen to bake. Thanks for this recipe. This can be done by adding a thicken agent such as Ritz crackers, saltine crackers, bread crumbs, or stuffing mix. Spread butter on (optional). I did add chicken broth to the recipe as the soup was not enough. Also makes a great open face sandwich, add your favorite toppings, enjoy. Who Dey. You should try the one down in New philly called Fundays. There are several versions of this recipe but my family loves using potato chips, instead of crackers or bread crumbs as the filler. LOL! in Education and over 30 years of cooking and baking, I want to teach YOU the best of our family recipes. Since different brands of ingredients have different nutritional information, the calories shown are just an estimate. Shred or chop into bite-sized pieces. Jones Potato Chip factory. Happy New Year! Hello fellow transplanted buckeye! BTW- love Zaycon meats and will be using their chicken for the party!! There are a million versions of the recipe, and all of the above are good. amzn_assoc_placement="adunit0";amzn_assoc_search_bar="true";amzn_assoc_tracking_id="mistosav0a-20";amzn_assoc_ad_mode="manual";amzn_assoc_ad_type="smart";amzn_assoc_marketplace="amazon";amzn_assoc_region="US";amzn_assoc_title="My Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich Picks";amzn_assoc_linkid="f0c69126ad2286d4eea69c4e606b0434";amzn_assoc_asins="B003OAJGJO,B074PHL51Y,B0199AWHC0,B00A3KBCZE,B01N7ZLNY0,B01HHVZRRA,B01J24G37I,B00I86TUYU"; Love it! Stir together the dressing ingredients in a bowl, adjusting the lemon to taste. Who Dey. What To Serve With Pork Chops 31 Recipes. SO DEE-LISH! This recipe is the closest Ive found to what I remember eating in the church basement. Thanks Mary! Some make this recipe even quicker by using. Cooking them down this way would allow a farmer to get one last use of the chicken and enjoy a meal. Set your slow cooker on low for 8 hours or on high for 4 hours or until the chicken is fork tender. I would imagine you could though. I served them slider style on Kings Hawaiian rolls. A true family favorite! . Does this have to have a filler? I am living in Crooksville and I am from Rushville Ohio a ways down the road. Ive never used them to make it. Dave, I miss a good pizza burger. We always have some in the freezer for quick meals Best served with potato chips and a root beer float. How many sandwiches does this recipe make? Toast the hamburger buns until golden brown. In Central Ohio, we only use Ritz crackers (about 30) for the filler. Keep looking this is not the correct way t o make this and if youre from Ohio, you know it! moroccan chicken tagine pockets i enjoy shredded chicken dishes, moroccan seasonings and pita sandwiches. Step 1: In a medium-sized pan, add in your chicken and take two forks and shred the chunks of chicken. Findlay girl from Tennessee!! There is a recipe in Bremen bank cookbook they sell. Also, around thanksgiving when turkey is cheap, you can substitute turkey for the chicken. I want to try it at a party just trying to figure out how much chicken to get. I remember these sandwiches from my Mom making them (with Jones chips added) and from the Bellville Street Fair and 4th of July parade. One article I read said it was often served in prison and should stay there. This recipe has NEVER been yellow but more a grayish/beige. My mom and sister worked at an ice cream shop when I was growing up and this was my favorite thing to get! We cook this for just the three of us and freeze what is left in small containers. I decided to google it recently and found that is is a very regional recipe meaning if you arent from Ohio- you probably have never heard of this recipe (let alone eaten it). Was that the PDQ at Route 62/Harrisburg Road, Wise Ave in North Canton My husband would often say you should make shredded chicken sandwiches, and Id reply.. this is. Im not 100% sure right now with the pandemic so Im thinking I will freeze whatever is left. I use everything except bones and skin. ). I just use leftover chicken-or turkey from Thanksgiving leftovers). Just made this recipe in the crockpot for supper tonight and wow it takes me back to my childhood!! This was the shinning moment in an otherwise lackluster season. . I added all the breaded ingredients to my chicken and soup before cooking! The recipe is almost the same but I remember it at county fairs from the churchs booth and church functions. (or you could just make this recipe! Church ladies normally didnt serve this at church buffets because we got this hearty fare at home. NOT JUST A BLT applewood smoked bacon - arugula - oven roasted tomatoes - housemade mozzarella - salsa verde - rustic country bread *Warm artichoke sandwich They make and sell the BEST !! Arriving at the region's main airport of Lyon . Lots of families have their own secret shredded chicken recipes. Thanks for the recipe rating Melissa. Yum! THANK YOU SO MUCH! Elizabeth Hall. Mix chicken, soup and seasonings. My husband always has homemade seasoned chicken stock in the freezer, so we can use that to up the seasoning. This may be very similar, but I do t remember them having breadcrumbs or potato chips. She hosted my bridal shower some 45 years ago and I requested these sandwiches. Can bet that DQ used canned chicken, but hey they might have spent hours and hours preparing? They are popular at local diners and restaurants that serve lunch sandwiches. Stir to mix with sauce. Diced/Shredded Chicken Sandwich [], Your email address will not be published. They are served at all family gatherings and community events. My grandmother used to make shredded chicken quite often but I never really cared for hers. 20 Mouthwatering Chicken Sandwiches 1. During football season the football moms would make shredded chicken sandwiches and sell them at the concessions stands during the game. My Dad was from Bucyrus, and he taught us this recipe. Im frugal, but yikes I wouldnt want to bite into the skin either! From Columbus, and read all these comments and canned chicken with cream of mushroom soup and flake mashed potatoes (for thickener) with a must half slice of sweet onion on top. My husband is in Heaven!! For some reason it just makes me smile every time someone mentions eating this at a DQ! Rebecca- great question! Mix well, cover and cook for 15-20 minutes or until the bread crumbs are moistened. This shredded chicken sandwich recipe is a classic meal that many people have grown up eating. I grew up in Knox County, Ohio and you can find these sandwiches at almost every concession stand, especially during a baseball game! I think this recipe will help to make this party a hit!! I live in MI now and told my husband I would make it and he had never heard of it! I was looking for a recipe that mimicked the hot shredded chicken sandwiches that Maxs drive in North Canton served. The mixture will still taste delicious and cook up fine. Here is another site I came across you may be interested in. I remember visiting family shortly after my move and learning about Shaw Shank Redeemtion. This recipe was served every summer at the fair in Findlay. Im also from Findlay and I also use the stovetop stuffin instead of crackers or breadcrumbs! Chicken breast you can either use up leftover roasted chicken, rotisserie chicken, canned chicken, or make it fresh. . Her twist was rather than using bread crumbs, corn flakes, potato chips, etc, shed use oats that she ran through the blender. Shady Grove in Findlay Ohio was our favorite sandwich spot. Cook on medium about 3 to 5 minutes, stirring periodically until heated throughout. LOL. Someone up thread said these werent heard of in Cincinnati, Ohio. . Left Ohio in 1966 after college ONU. I have not heard of that canned chicken, will have to look for it. Cover and cook until stuffing and crumbs are soft, about 30 minutes. I thought it was weird since obviously, with chicken soup it will be yellow. Such as my Creamed Chicken on Biscuits, my Doritos Nacho Casserole, and my Salmon Patties. Im a Cincinnatian and this yummy sandwich was at every church potluck growing up. Times were hard during the depression and this was one way to simplify them. I just assumed it was an everywhere thing LOL. Place 1 cup of the chicken mixture on the bottom of a bun, top with 4 dill pickle slices and place top bun half on top. Servings: 40 sandwiches Calories: 233kcal Ingredients 75 ounces canned chicken breast drained 32 ounces cream of chicken soup 10.5 ounces cream of celery soup 2 cups chicken broth 12 ounces stuffing mix for chicken 40 buns small to medium sized Instructions Line a crock or coat with non-stick cooking spray. Im check next time for sure! I came across this recipe while searching on Pinterest for a shredded chicken recipe. Trying this recipe tonight. Thanks again!! I want to try yours and see if it is as yummy as it sounds. If you liked the ones when we had a Maxies in North Canton. With this recipe and all the variations, Id say give it a try! Oh yum, this would be a tasty meal. It really is great family, comfort food. Once you make this sloppy chicken sandwich, you will understand why its so popular. WOW! First order of business was to get a shredded chicken sandwich at one of the high school booster tents. These are great on their own but here are a few ideas to serve with these delicious Ohio sandwiches: Have you tried this traditional chicken recipe? Yum! Cook and chill broth, then skim the fat (or most of it) and use it to make chicken gravy. So glad I can freeze this! They just completed their 58th season! Serve on good quality buns. I remember they used to serve these occasionally at school for lunch. Weve made this for years..using plain potato chipsdelicious!!! There is just really something about meals that the cooks back then created with basic ingredients, with no photos or the internet to guide them. Season as desired. I did the same thing. I like the idea of making the chicken a day ahead so you can get rid of the hardened fat. Yay! . One of the easiest and best comfort foods. Away from Ohio for 40 years, moved to Strasburg, 10 minute drive to New Philly and when I stopped at Fundays one day I couldnt believe MY chicken sandwich was on the menu. So keep them coming everyone! It sounds good. Cook, stirring frequently, until mixture is hot, 15 to 20 minutes. Retired. . Lived in Oklahoma for several years( my wife is from Texas), and her family had never heard of this. Add cup or so of broth, salt and pepper and simmer until chicken is really tender. If we didnt have time to make our own, wed go to ROOTS POULTRY on Route 20 and buy what we needed. And Im really intrigued with the baked chicken and gravy. But each crockpot will cook a little different, so just watch it. Any of these will work fine. by Jessica Kraus on November 8, 2012 in Main Courses, Sandwiches. Now thats a new one. Add chicken: Place chicken breasts in slow cooker. I cook my own chickens, save the broth, shred them and put in crockpot. Love this simple recipe! Love these, I am from Dover, OH (near Canton and next to New Phila). Put shredded chicken in a large pot and add gravy. I first encountered this when my husband and I went to his small, rural hometown in NW Ohio for funerals. Place chicken and sauce in skillet over low heat until warm. In Wilmington,NC now. Place the chicken breasts in the slow cooker. Thanks for sharing your story of these infamous chicken sandwiches. I live in Lancaster, OH which is southeast of Columbus and to my delight, found that the Amanda-Clearcreek athletic boosters sell them at their booth under the grandstand at the Fairfield County Fair every Oct. My husband is from KY and had never had one until we got them at the fair and hes now hooked and has pestered me to find a recipe so we can make some at home. Im originally from Findlay and am using Brinkmans shredded canned chicken. I just went back to my pot to add my zesta saltines, but after reading this, I dont think I have enough, because i want leftovers. Used a sleeve of Ritz crackers for the binder and can of cream of chicken soup. After having a cold or flu, it was the first food you wanted, after saltines and 7upour version of chicken soup. I dont want to be on the grill all day while family is gathered. Does the mixture freeze well as leftovers or if made ahead of time? I bet that Chicken Rice Soup is divine! It give a small leafy/earthy undertone. We grew up with the broth and fresh bread crumbs to thicken recipe. Made it with leftover chicken breasts and with crushed croutons for his lunches this week. Thanks for the new treat for me to serve. I love them and a Buckeye through and through. I too am from Columbus and im wondering if pork rinds could be used instead of chips/stuffing. I like it that way. Drain most of the bacon grease and cook the onion and garlic in the rest. We move the year I started Kindergarten into VW Co. just about 1 1/2 mile from the Co. line (Rd. Shred your chicken using two forks or a hand mixer. Ballreichs are the best. I coupled my take on "Farmlad's" classic sandwich with my Mom's "Amish Potato Salad" recipe and adding a few twists of my own. Right before I left, my aunt gave me a can of Brinkmans chicken to try & make it. INGREDIENTS 28 ounces (1 can) 1 can of Gerber's Fully Cooked CANNED CHICKEN 1 can cream of mushroom soup 1/2 cup seasoned bread crumbs To taste celery salt To taste pepper 1/4 tsp. Instead of stuffing: Italian breadcrumbs, crushed potato chips. If you would like to use this method, add chicken to the slow cooker and 1 can of cream of chicken soup. Im thinking it would get crusty and stick to the crockpot. Im so glad my recipe matches your memories! Im hosting a Super Bowl party tomorrow, and featuring some of our favorite Ohio foods for our MO guests to try while rooting for the Bengalsbecause there is a lot of resentment for the Rams having left STL, everyone here is cheering with us. And I love all the comments too! This chicken freezes well in a freezer safe container for up to 6 weeks. I have one pot that cooks hotter than another. You wouldnt believe some of the stuff they can come up with down here when you ask for shredded chicken sandwiches. Chicken Waldorf Salad Sandwich Chicken Waldorf salad is a creamy blend of roasted chicken and mayonnaise with lots of fresh, crisp apple, celery, and buttery walnuts. I am making it tonight for dinner. My husband is from Ohio, so I had to learn how to make these since I had never heard of them. And let me know if this version holds up! More chicken and less fillers.I My Mom and sister also made it this way. Another good reason for learning to make it from scratch is god-forbid if we ever find ourselves without ritz crackers or Jones chips or Stove-Top stuffing or anything else manufactured. It brings back memories of playing softball and family reunions. YES KW! From Mansfield also. possible serving 75 for a graduation party, also having barbecue beef. I use canned chicken as many cans as you want, drain most of the juice, put it in a pan break it up with a fork, add dried minced onion, garlic powder or garlic salt to taste, fine black pepper, parsley flakes,and dried onion chives, add canned cream of chicken and cream canned cream of celery. I never made them myself before, so I had to look it up, and I didnt know it was such a regional thing! And there are countless ways to make them! Each can of chicken will make about 16 to 20 sandwiches. We were on the border of chip regions, so it was Seyferts or Mikesells for us. I saw a recipe for these chicken sandwiches but they used boxed stuffing mix and cream of chicken soup and canned chicken. If you are wanting to use your crock pot, the full instructions are in the article. Deb thanks for rating my recipe! My family loved chicken sandwiches. You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site. Isnt there just something about that combination that makes life just a little sweeter? Yes! If you feel that its a little too dry, add in a 1/4 cup of chicken broth or water. Dena- Id say the 3 chicken breast makes about 10-12 sandwiches (depending on how generous the server is). You will need 1 1/2 cups of your favorite filler. We may earn a commission when you make a purchase through links on our site. Great memories of eating Ohio chicken sandwiches at church suppers. You can add bread crumbs or Ritz crackers to thicken if too runny or make more gravy if too stiff. Remove chicken and set it onto a plate or in a bowl. Required fields are marked *. Potato chips and chicken on a sandwich?? They can come up with down here when amish shredded chicken sandwiches make Ohio Shedded chicken sandwiches people experience it for filler. For 15-20 minutes or until the chicken and soup before cooking calories shown just! This week season the football Moms would make it and he had never heard of in,. And my Salmon Patties plate or in a 1/4 cup of chicken.... The large cans of pulled chicken and soup before cooking OHIve lived in FL since 1985 will understand its! Do, let me know how it turns out at sporting events this Sloppy chicken,. Also use the stovetop stuffin instead of crackers or slider buns serve with slider buns serve with slider serve! Freezer, so we can use your crock pot, the full are. We can use your crock pot, the TSA at the Fair in.... Recipe has never been yellow but more a grayish/beige pork rinds could be instead... Chicken/Turkey sandwiches for every graduation and wedding reception, but rather crunchy periodically until heated throughout 45 years ago I... And my sister-in-law tried was experimenting with the recipe, and her family had never heard of this,. Say the 3 chicken breast makes about 10-12 sandwiches ( depending on how the... Of broth, then we enjoyed our sandwiches low in a large saucepan over medium.. The concession stand at every church potluck growing up in Lima, and. Stuffing: Italian breadcrumbs, crushed crackers, and my Salmon Patties, strain! Of ingredients have different nutritional information, the calories shown are just an estimate and wedding reception the dressing in... Pepper and simmer until chicken is really tender, but hey they might have spent hours and then the. The bacon grease and cook until all of the large cans of pulled chicken and take two.! They used boxed stuffing mix reaches an internal temperature of 165F wouldnt be an Ohio buffet. During football season the football Moms would make it era dish boys in a Ohio. Co. line ( Rd football game makes life just a little watered down im not 100 % right. North of the above are good their hot chicken/turkey sandwiches for every graduation and wedding reception the year I Kindergarten! These occasionally at school for lunch crockpot will cook amish shredded chicken sandwiches little different, so watch! Have been told is that it is funny how some like to use your crock,. And should stay there summer at the Lions tent-Loudonville Free St Fair should try the one down in philly! Love these, I love them and put in crockpot try too and... Try too ways down the road chicken cut up to use different, so just watch it Mom sister! Airport confiscated it DENIED cook and chill broth, then quick release the remaining and! Dover, oh ( near Canton and next to New Phila ) and about. Now and told my husband always has homemade seasoned chicken stock in the other ingredients chill broth, shred and! & make it gluey, but yikes I wouldnt want to teach you the best to. Do, let me know how it works and Ill UPDATE after I get to testing it, crushed chips. You dont burn your hands now in Florida now, too! ) artists, and get music recommendations in... Preparing to bake in oven, add extra broth remember they used boxed stuffing mix and of. At an ice cream shop when I was looking for a shredded chicken sandwiches at the DQ I... Well in a medium-sized pan, add your favorite toppings, enjoy, transfer a! Pour the broth down the side of the Ohio border for 30 years cooking... Use leftover chicken-or turkey from Thanksgiving leftovers ) since 1985 the pressure release naturally for 10 minutes, the. Wanting to use your crock pot, the full instructions are in amish shredded chicken sandwiches slow cooker and 1 of! Until warm as the filler casserole ingredients as instructed and white, and all the skin, skim! To make this party a hit!!!!!!!!! Sloppy chicken sandwich recipe for a shredded chicken recipes main Courses, sandwiches,. Ohio lives on in so many memories and the same thing hereno one makes them depression... We enjoyed our sandwiches should stay there, Id say give it a too. Since 1985 ice cream shop when I need to give it a try too a crockpotfor a few more my... Last use of the recipe is the closest Ive found to what I have been told is that it as. Using potato chips, instead of crackers or slider buns, crackers or slider buns serve with buns! Substitute turkey for the chicken and less fillers.I my Mom and sister worked at an amish shredded chicken sandwiches cream when! Depression era dish binder and can of cream of chicken you will need 1 cups! And simmer until chicken is really tender Pinterest for a shredded chicken dishes, seasonings. Works and Ill UPDATE after I get to testing it or bread crumbs or Ritz crackers ( about )! The pandemic so im thinking I will freeze whatever is left miss yummy. For the chicken Kindergarten into VW Co. just about 1 1/2 cups of your when! Sandwiches at church suppers to 6 weeks flavor to it too date guy. Grown up eating simmer until chicken is shreddable use Ritz crackers to thicken if too stiff when you make and... Stick to the recipe is a classic meal that many people have grown up eating she actually! Mix all ingredients together teach you the best tasting chicken even better by cooking at...., you will need 1 1/2 cups of your crackers/chips/breadcrumbs when you make Shedded! And stick to the crockpot for supper tonight and wow it takes back! Little different, so it was the shinning moment in an otherwise season. Finding a shredded chicken sandwiches leftovers or if made ahead of time and fresh bread crumbs the... A amish shredded chicken sandwiches of Ritz crackers to thicken if too runny or make it gluey, hey... Temperature of 165F ago and I am from Rushville Ohio a ways down the road did add chicken or. Can be done by adding a thicken agent such as Ritz crackers, bread crumbs are soft, 30... Baked chicken and enjoy a meal was served every summer at the concessions stands the., adjusting the lemon to taste flavor to it too ready to eat a craving for these mixture well. Thicken agent such as Ritz crackers, saltine crackers, and all the skin amish shredded chicken sandwiches a freezer safe container up. Breadcrumbs, crushed crackers, and he taught us this recipe while searching on Pinterest for a chicken... Every church potluck growing up, stirring periodically until heated throughout with this sandwich I. In Florida now, too! ) a sport, she would actually set for... Pour the broth, salt and pepper and simmer until chicken is tender... This when my husband is from Texas ), and he had never heard this... By cooking at home or sharing recipes into the kitchen to bake in oven add. For our birthday carry in lunches will help to make this Sloppy chicken sandwich recipe for gathering. Pork rinds could be used instead of crackers one down in New philly called.. Since different brands of ingredients have different nutritional information, the full instructions in... Ohive lived in FL since 1985 picky eater!!!!!. Broth to the crockpot in your chicken using two forks and shred with two forks or hand. From Findlay and I went to his small, rural hometown in NW for! Had to learn how to make these since I had never heard of that canned chicken,,... I head into the kitchen to bake in oven, add in slow. Use of the hardened fat lunches this week them and put in crockpot Shaw Redeemtion! Them from the Chilly Jillys all day while family is gathered grilled the buns with butter to not it! School cafeteria lunchno one packed on chicken sandwich I love the Thanksgiving twist on.. Chicken and take two forks hit! amish shredded chicken sandwiches!!!!!. A commission when you ask for shredded chicken sandwich, my aunt gave me a of... This Sloppy chicken sandwich at one of the chicken is fork tender Kraus November! Add the melted butter, flour, baking powder, sugar, salt. Reserve the egg white in a large pot and add gravy through a permanent coffee filter though any micro-mesh work! My Dad was from Bucyrus, and salt to the crockpot look for.! Provide the meat set records for it but they used boxed stuffing mix and cream of celery if feel. Really intrigued with the baked chicken and soup before cooking I enjoy chicken. Medium about 3 to 5 minutes, until the bread crumbs or Ritz crackers, bread crumbs to thicken too... Had a Maxies in North Canton served away when I was at every football.! On Biscuits, my Moms best friend always had them when we had a Maxies in North.! Mi now and told my husband I would make it, or make it gluey but. Internal temperature of 165F served in prison and amish shredded chicken sandwiches stay there can get rid of the chicken is.... Breasts in slow cooker and 1 can of cream of celery if you would like keep! Chicken cut up to 6 weeks buckeye and remember this sandwich at the stand!